Light and darkness in divine revelation: a constructive study of Thomas Aquinas's commentary on the Book of Isaiah
2025 (English)Doctoral thesis, monograph (Other academic)Alternative title
Ljus och mörker i gudomlig uppenbarelse : en konstruktiv studie av Thomas av Aquinos kommentar till Jesajas bok (Swedish)
Abstract [en]
The commentary on the Book of Isaiah is one of Thomas Aquinas's lesser known works. The biblical commentaries of Aquinas have been the focus of much research in the last few decades, discovering important nuances in his theological thinking. The present study seeks to continue that work. More importantly, it wants to give a constructive proposal for a contemporary Thomistic biblical theology, as a contribution to the contemporary discussion about theological exgesis of the Bible.
Those who seek to interpret the Bible theologically often struggle with the findings of modern biblical scholarship, who have historically been very critical of doctrinal interpretations of the biblical text. Matthew Levering has conducted research into the hermeneutical principles of Aquinas, which he calls "participatory biblical exegesis." The reason for the name is the paramount importance that Aquinas's metaphysical doctrine of participation plays in Aquinas's biblical hermeneutics. Levering argues that Aquinas's particular notion of participation has the potential to balance properly the theological concern to treat the Bible as a unified divine revelation with the complex history of the biblical texts that seems to contradict the view of the Bible as a unified message. This study utilizes Levering's notion of participatory biblical exegesis as a theoretical framework. It also seeks to develop Levering's notion with the help of Rudi A. te Velde's research on Aquinas's doctrine of participation. The focus of this study is the theme of light and darkness that appears in Aquinas's Isaiah commentary, distilling the theological and philosophical ideas that underlie Aquinas's exegesis.
The dissertation is divided into five parts. Part I contains the background of the study. Part II examines light and darkness in relation to prophetic knowledge, analyzing Aquinas's understanding of Isaiah's prophecy. Part III centers on Aquinas's view of light as knowledge and good moral action (or disposition), darkness as ignorance and sinful acts (or disposition), and how this dynamic is present both in the people of God and their enemies in the Book of Isaiah. In addition, Aquinas's understanding of the notion of judgment in Isaiah will be analyzed, as this unites the aspects of knowledge and moral disposition treated in part III. Part IV deals with how Aquinas considers Jesus Christ to be the source of light in the Book of Isaiah. However, as this study is not mainly a historical treatment but a constructive proposal, throughout these parts, the study seeks to relate Aquinas's hermeneutical principles to the contemporary discussion of how to interpret the Bible theologically. In connection to this, the study treats topics like biblical inspiration and authorship, the importance of judgment in biblical interpretation, and Christological readings of the Book of Isaiah (and the Old Testament in general). In this regard, the main interlocutors are Brevard S. Childs and Christopher R. Seitz, biblical scholars who have sought to combine historical-critical methods with the theological idea of the Bible as divine revelation. Part V in particular contains principles proposed for a contemporary Thomistic biblical theology, like the unity of the Bible, the relationship between the Old and New testaments, figural reading, the rule of faith, and the relationship between history and ontology.
While Aquinas's biblical exegesis is insufficient its historical analysis and bear noticeable marks of his time period, this study has nonetheless found that Aquinas's theological and philosophical ideas can be valuable tools in formulating a biblical theology that wants to take the complex historical reality into account when theologically interpreting the Bible as a unified divine message. Particularly, Aquinas's idea of things participating in God's being and knowledge combined with the notion of the independence of substantial beings provide a fundamental view that metaphysically ties the intricate and multifaceted dimension of human existence to the unity of divine being and knowledge, without reducing one to the other. It is thus not merely a repetition of Aquinas's hermeneutical principles, but a constructive reworking of them, in order to let them bear on the contemporary academic discussion about interpreting the Bible theologically.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
Umeå: Umeå University, 2025. , p. 363
Keywords [en]
Thomas Aquinas, Biblical Theology, Theological Exegesis, Book of Isaiah, Participation, Biblical Hermeneutics, Canonical Approach
National Category
Religious Studies
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:umu:diva-243497ISBN: 978-91-8070-752-7 (print)ISBN: 978-91-8070-753-4 (electronic)OAI: oai:DiVA.org:umu-243497DiVA, id: diva2:1992051
Public defence
2025-09-24, Hummelhonung (HUM.D.210), Humanisthuset, Petrus Laestadius väg, 907 36 Umeå, Umeå, 13:15 (English)
Opponent
Supervisors
2025-09-032025-08-262025-09-03Bibliographically approved