Självkostnadsprincipen i kommersiellentreprenad: Om skälighetsbedömning vid löpande räkning och Ändring av entreprenad enligt AB 04, ABT 06, AB 25 och ABPU 25
2025 (Swedish)Independent thesis Advanced level (professional degree), 20 credits / 30 HE credits
Student thesis
Abstract [en]
The legal position regarding whether a reasonableness review of the price is possible when the prime cost principle is agreed upon under the standard agreements in commercial construction is unclear. This thesis presents the most reasonable interpretation, based on the established method for interpreting standard agreements developed by the Swedish Supreme Court. This method allows guidance from default legal provisions. Accordingly, the analysis focuses on Section 45 of the Swedish Sale of Goods Act and Section 36 of the Consumer Services Act, which may be analogously applied to commercial construction in certain circumstances. These sections require that the price is not agreed upon.
Commercial construction is characterised by being complicated and unpredictable. These projects are primarily regulated by standard agreements, namely AB 04 and ABT 06. These standard agreements are currently undergoing revision, and the updated versions, AB 25 and ABPU 25, are expected to replace the previous standard agreements in 2025.
A common form of compensation in commercial construction are cost plus contracts. Cost plus contract is reimbursed by the prime cost principle. Even in fixed price contracts, or contracts with other compensation forms, is contract variations often reimbursed according to the prime cost principle. Therefore, the prime cost principle is of great importance in the majority of commercial construction governed by these standard agreements.
The only certain way for the employer to question the contractor’s proven costs, when the prime cost principle is applied, is by questioning the contractor’s adherence to its duty of care. However, the burden of proof lies with the employer, and proving such a breach is often difficult in practice.
Relevant case law is examined in the thesis to assess whether cost based on the prime cost principle constitutes a sufficiently defined pricing basis. While some judgments suggest that the prime cost principle in standard agreements defines the pricing mechanism clearly enough to preclude such review, others, such as the Gripenhus case from 2016, indicate that a reasonableness review may still be assessed regarding pricing components that remain unregulated.
The thesis findings are that although the legal situation is uncertain, it is reasonable to apply the same principle to commercial contracts as to consumer contracts, particularly since commercial employers may not be better positioned to prevent overcharging than consumers. Consequently, it may be possible to conduct a reasonableness review of unregulated components of the prime cost principle. However, the specific terms agreed upon between the parties should always be considered in the final legal assessment.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
2025.
Keywords [en]
Reasonableness review, cost plus contracts, prime cost, fixed price, standard agreement, commercial construction
Keywords [sv]
Entreprenad, avtal, standardavtal, ändring, ÄTA, självkostnadsprincipen, skälighetsbedömning, AB 04, ABT 06, AB 25, ABPU 25, löpande räkning, kommersiell entreprenad, ändringsarbete, entreprenadrätt, entreprenadarbete, Gripenhus, Nybropalatset, Enstar, Björnvägen, White, Metallslangfabriken, Bokföringstjänsten
National Category
Law
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:su:diva-245523OAI: oai:DiVA.org:su-245523DiVA, id: diva2:1988965
Supervisors
Examiners
2025-08-142025-08-142025-08-14Bibliographically approved