This study investigates the impact of Emergency Vehicle Approaching (EVA) warnings on driver behaviour, focusing on different modalities and the effects of false warnings. While previous research has established the safety benefits of EVA warnings, this study seeks to investigate and perhaps solidify existing theoretical frameworks regarding warning modalities and false warnings. The study, conducted in Sweden, involved participants driving in a simulator, the simulation consisted of driving along a three-lane highway. During the simulation each participant got three EVA warnings, these were all either visual or auditory. Two of the warnings were true meaning the participants were passed by an emergency vehicle, and one of the warnings was false meaning an emergency vehicle never appeared. The order of these warnings was either True/False/True or False/True/True. Analysis of how much participants delayed the emergency vehicle suggested a potential learning curve effect. False warnings, however, exhibited a recency effect, impacting participants’ responses to subsequent true warnings. The order of warnings influenced participants’ perceptions, with false warnings possibly reducing system credibility and task performance. There was a significant difference in delay times between modalities for the last true warning, whereas the auditive warning produced a significantly lower delay time. Subjective perceptions of behaviour were also observed. The difference in effect depending on modality was significant when participants were asked to assess the effect of the false warning on their behaviour. Theoretical frameworks such as multiple resource theory and the c-hip model supported these findings. Limitations included factors such as the experiment environment, loss of control group and the interpretation of Likert statements. Despite these limitations, the study provides valuable insights into the effectiveness of EVA warnings and the implications of false warnings on driver behavior, informing the development of more efficient warning systems for emergency vehicles.