A Study in Structural Materials by Lifecycle Assessment: How reconstructions can be done to promote sustainability
2024 (English)Independent thesis Advanced level (degree of Master (One Year)), 10 credits / 15 HE credits
Student thesis
Abstract [en]
This report compares the environmental impact regarding carbon dioxide equivalent emitted from two building principles:
1. Reuse of concrete structure while adding a timber structure on top
2. Demolition of concrete structure and construct an entirely new structure in timber.
The results are calculated using life cycle analyses, with data for concrete-, steel-, and wooden materials and their global warming potential from every phase of the lifecycle. The data is collected from the software OneClick LCA and from EPDs from material manufacturers.
The comparisons further include two variations of the performed scenarios where all steel fastenings are replaced with a BiteLock system where no screws, nails or brackets are used in the timber construction. The result showed that by removing the steel materials the climate impact interms of carbon dioxide equivalents decreased with 18 % for the first scenario and with 22 % for the second scenario.
Results from production-, and construction phase only, showed that scenario 1 is more profitable than scenario 2 with calculated emissions of 763 tons CO2-equivalents for the first mentioned versus 1080 tons CO2-equivalents for the later scenario. Thus, the variation of scenario 2 with no steel fixtures performs the lowest calculated emissions at 334 tons CO2-equivalents, while the variation of scenario 1 performs 465 tons CO2-equivalents at production, - and construction phase. In the end-of-life stage both variations of scenario 2 increase to 2742 and 3495 ton CO2-equivalents due to burning the biofuel. Both variations of scenario 1 increase at the end-of-lifestage but with lower emissions than the previous at 1704 and 1403 ton CO2-equivalents. The difference between the performed values from both scenarios is due to removing all steel material. Further, according to after-life calculations, concrete carbonization occurs and contributed to savings of 44 890 kg CO2-equivalents for scenario 1 and savings about 11 120kg CO2-equivalents for scenario 2.
Finally, results show that both to reuse a concrete structure and to demolish and construct a new timber frame are two environmentally profitable options when compared to a newly constructed concrete structure. The two studied scenarios can save between 1039 to 3132 tons CO2-equivalents compared to construction a new concrete structure.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
2024.
Keywords [en]
reuse, lifecycle assessment, concrete structure, cross laminated timber, steel fixtures, climate impact
National Category
Energy Systems
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:du-49178OAI: oai:DiVA.org:du-49178DiVA, id: diva2:1885849
Subject / course
Energy Technology
2024-08-282024-07-262025-10-09