Is Tougher Application of Article 22 of the EU Merger Control the Deal Breaker?: Examining the Commission's Enforcement Against Killer Acquisitions in the Digital Economy
2024 (English)Independent thesis Advanced level (degree of Master (One Year)), 10 credits / 15 HE credits
Student thesis
Abstract [en]
Background: The European Merger Regulation (EUMR) has evolved with new guidelines, reflecting a more interventionist approach and increasing uncertainty for businesses. In the digital economy, innovation is key. Large firms, especially tech giants such as Google, Amazon, Facebook, Apple, and Microsoft (collectively known as GAFAM), acquire startups to enhance specialization. However this practice may also hinder competition and innovation through so called "Killer Acquisitions". The EUMR evaluates mergers to safeguard consumer welfare and competitive environments. Nonetheless, the low turnovers of start-ups present challenges. In response, the European Commission updated Article 22 of the EUMR in 2021, allowing review of mergers that fall below the usual turnover-based thresholds due to their significant impact on competition, adding complexity and uncertainty to the merger review process.
Problem and Purpose: The lack of clear interpretation of Article 22 and the Commission's limited powers create legal uncertainty in merger control. Continuous revisions of merger guidelines have not clearly identified enforcement gaps. Traditional theories of harm are inadequate for digital mergers, where platform ecosystems and data-driven economies are crucial. Businesses face unpredictability regarding if, when, or by whom their transactions will be scrutinized. In 2023, the European Commission reinterpreted Article 22 EUMR to oversee non-EU dimension mergers without changing thresholds, a move that is debated. This reflects a trade-off between overenforcement and underenforcement.
Research aim: to analyse how the Commission can balance Article 22 regarding maximum market effectiveness, with adherence to legal principles such as legal certainty, the rule of law, and predictability.
Method: This research is a qualitative study, undertaking a mix of legal and business methodologies. Data was collected via desk research.
Conclusion: The intensified merger control enforcement via Article 22 EUMR reflects concerns about market concentration and its impact on competition and innovation. However, the actual prevalence of killer acquisitions in digital markets is limited, and the regulatory5approach introduces legal uncertainty for businesses. A balanced framework is essential to ensure effective competition and legal certainty, with complementary measures like the DMA and Article 102 TFEU addressing enforcement gaps without stifling innovation. In conclusion, while renewed merger control is crucial for competitive markets, the approach must be refined to avoid overreach and align with market realities, preserving the goals of the EUMR and fostering competition and innovation.
Place, publisher, year, edition, pages
2024. , p. 58
Keywords [en]
merger control, competition law, EU law, killer acquisition, innovation, abuse of dominance, antitrust, online platforms, digital market
National Category
Social Sciences Law Business Administration
Identifiers
URN: urn:nbn:se:uu:diva-534482OAI: oai:DiVA.org:uu-534482DiVA, id: diva2:1882101
Subject / course
Commercial Law
Educational program
Master's Programme in International and European Law and Business
Supervisors
Examiners
2024-07-052024-07-042024-07-05Bibliographically approved