Latin America has experienced numerous transitions between autocratic and democratic rule since the region's independence from European colonization. Today, the democratic status substantially varies in the region and two of the countries that show the most significant difference are the Central American neighbours of Costa Rica and Nicaragua. Costa Rica is considered one of the world's most stable democracies while Nicaragua is on the opposite side of the spectrum. Using the theoretical tool of path dependency, this thesis aims to analyze the factors and critical junctures that have contributed to or hindered democratic development in Costa Rica and Nicaragua from 1900 to 2022. For Costa Rica, one of the most important turning points was the abolition of the military in 1948. This decision not only reduced the risk of military coups, but also paved the way to constructing a welfare state and establishing regular and fair elections, playing a crucial role in reinforcing democracy and political stability in the country. In contrast, Nicaragua's democratic development has been marked by recurring conflicts and dictatorial regimes. Critical junctures include the Sandinista revolutionin 1979, overthrowing the Somoza dictatorship. This initially resulted in democratic progress but was again followed by political instability and autocratic leadership.